News12 New York
Where to Watch
Download the App
Local
Crime
Weather
beWell
The East End
Crime Files

Democrat wins Fairfield first selectman race after rowdy recount

In the final tally, Democrat Bill Gerber defeated Republican incumbent Brenda Kupchick by a razor-thin 37-vote margin.

John Craven

Nov 14, 2023, 6:53 PM

Updated

Share:

Democrats will take over Fairfield’s first selectman seat after a Tuesday recount where tempers flared.

In the final tally, Democrat Bill Gerber defeated Republican incumbent Brenda Kupchick by a razor-thin 37-vote margin.

"We are grateful to everyone who came out to make their voices heard on Election Day, as we intend to create a government that works for and is inclusive of all citizens," Gerber said in a statement Tuesday night. "I also want to thank First Selectwoman Brenda Kupchick for her dedication and service to the people of Fairfield."

RAUCOUS RECOUNT

Even before the first ballots were counted, the accusations started flying. Democrats and Republicans got in shouting matches over everything from cameras in the ballot-counting area to where observers were allowed to sit.

“Any party representative shall be put in the position where they can observe each ballot and the marking on each ballot,” said Connecticut Republican Party chair Ben Proto. “These observers cannot view that.”

Democrats fired back.

“There's no rule in statute of how many feet separation,” said Steven Sheinberg, Fairfield’s Democratic Town Committee chair. “I think there was about 3 to 4 feet separation between the observers and the checkers.”

HIGH STAKES, HIGH DRAMA

As a closely watched swing district, Fairfield is a top prize for both political parties.

Tensions were already high before Tuesday’s recount. Last week, police were called to a possible break-in at a ballot storage building. Turns out that it was just a torn window screen.

“The reason for the state police to take over the investigation was to maintain the integrity of the democratic process,” Fairfield Police Lt. Ed Nook told News 12 Connecticut on Friday.

Fairfield’s Republican voter registrar first notified authorities, according to Kupchick. The town’s two registrars have been engaged in an ongoing feud that even led to a police report and State Elections Enforcement Commission complaints last year.

Proto said he just wanted the recount to be fair.

“We really don't want Fairfield to become Bridgeport,” he said. “And unfortunately, the Democrat moderator and the Democrat registrar seem to be taking Fairfield toward the Bridgeport model.”

Sheinberg called it fear-mongering.

“Because the Republicans are losing or have lost in the initial count, they want to sow doubt in this process,” he said.

Top Stories

00:34
RIDGEFIELD PARK FIRE

Crews battle large residential fire in Ridgefield Park

01:12
37d563d1-c779-4f7e-877a-2673f753c7b0

Still a chill today before showers and a brief warmup

01:47
Screenshot 2026-04-20 051741

3 deadly crashes in less than 30 days stun South Brunswick

00:25
marijuana image update

Marijuana use rises among young adult women, annual substance report finds

00:35
NJ Power & Politics

Analilia Mejia officially takes over Gov. Sherrill’s former congressional seat

02:34
RETomthebosspkg_2026-04-20-22-16-34

Bruce Springsteen returns to the Garden State with Prudential Center show

01:45
REpatersonchrisshootingnew_2026-04-20-18-09-40

Search continues for gunman who shot four in Paterson

01:58
RTNJControlledFireAlstedeFarmsJFord10pm_2026-04-20-22-27-18

N.J. farms battle late-season freeze with creative measures to protect crops

00:48
RTNJJerseyProud04202026VO10pm_2026-04-20-22-28-01

Jersey Proud: Runner thanks EMTs who saved him after cardiac arrest during Asbury Park Half Marathon

01:59
REjenniheartattack420_2026-04-20-17-57-56

Rep. Gottheimer introduces 'Marcus' Law' to require cardiac screenings for student-athletes

00:45
RTNJ420DronePizzaDeliveryVOSOT1030pm_2026-04-20-22-52-22

Drone delivery first: Pizza goes to new heights in Montville

JASON BACON BLUR

Former Brick Township man who fled before trial sentenced to 32 years in drug and gun case

00:22
FIFA World Cup

American Dream opens registration for 39-day La Plaza de Fútbol ahead of FIFA World Cup

00:33
ElectionPollWorkerJobs2_2026-04-20-17-44-56

Union County seeking poll workers ahead of Election Day

00:19
Jakub Cielemecki Blur

Saddle Brook man charged with possession of child sexual abuse material in Bergen County investigation

stabbing arrest

Wallington man charged with attempted murder of 74-year-old in Strong Street stabbing, prosecutors say

00:23
sephora

Sephora now required to have warnings on skincare products not suitable for children under 13 following investigation

01:39
WCHVWoodburyGucciRobBGomezSG001

Police: $30K worth of handbags stolen from Gucci store at Woodbury Common; suspects flee to New Jersey

Credit: NYPD

Bald eagle rescued by NYPD from Hudson River has died

00:52
bloodhealth04020_2026-04-20-17-02-02_16-46-27,29

Red Cross: Having a diverse blood supply is vital due to constant need

App StoreGoogle Play Store

info

Newsletter

Send Photos/Videos

Contact

About Us

News Team

News 12 New York

follow us

Twitter

Facebook

Instagram

more resources

Optimum Corporate

Optimum Service

Advertise on News 12

Careers

Content Removal Policy

© 2026 N12N, LLC

Privacy Policy

Terms of Service

Ad Choices